Bergen County’s Tastiest Holiday Catering

Entertaining  / 

Sponsored Post: At Garden State Plaza, during the months of November and December, the more you spend the more you save if you’re a registered Westfield Rewards Program member. You can receive up to $600 back in Westfield Rewards points that will go right back into your Rewards account to be used towards more shopping or put towards your bills.  Sign up here to receive your perks!



While your holiday guestlist may be smaller this year, after the last few months we’ve all had, you may NOT want to cook the whole meal solo.  In case you are looking for some delicious assistance from the pro’s this holiday season, we’ve got you covered with our most favorite Bergen County caterers and bakers who will be serving up the whole meal to the most decadent desserts we have ever tasted!


La Promenade in Tenafly offers up a traditional holiday menu with creative twists such as orange ginger gravy, winter roasted ratatouille and coconut crusted pie.  You might as well take home some of their signature cronuts while you’re there, because ‘tis the season to indulge! @la_prom


Isabella’s Fine Foods and Catering in Closter offers up a full menu that is made with only the freshest of ingredients.  Locally adored, their whipped vanilla sweet potatoes are truly something special. @isabellasdeli


Foster Village Kosher Deli in Bergenfield is an institution in Bergen County when it comes to Kosher cooking!  With a traditional Thanksgiving menu offered this holiday season, you may also want to add in the Sloppy Joe sandwich platter, Nova Scotia salmon and white fish salad platter, and possibly some chicken schnitzel! @fostervillagekosherdeli


Maywood's Marketplace in Maywood boasts a seriously impressive selection of catering options that can be simplified for Thanksgiving with their “Two Tasty Options” curated menu, including of course an a la carte add-on menu to ensure you’re covering off on all the flavors. @maywoodsmarket


Uncle Giuseppe’s Marketplace in Ramsey is the largest establishment on our list, but we can’t ignore the Italian flavor they bring to the holiday table, being from NJ and all!  Every turkey needs a side of manicotti, no?! @unclegiuseppesmarketplace


B&M Food Market in Park Ridge is loved by so many in Bergen County, so leave it to them to not only have an extensive and diverse Thanksgiving menu, but of course they’ve also so thoughtfully included the “In-Law Special” which is a little taste of Thanksgiving dinner to drop off to the family members who won’t make it out this year. @bmmarketnj


Nonna’s Clementina in Closter has been serving up amazing Italian dishes and holiday platters for years, and their gorgeous antipasto and bruschetta platters will delight every holiday guest! @nonnaclementinadeli


Seafood Gourmet in Maywood specializes in creating beautiful platters of fresh seafood for every catering occasion, and is always a welcome food choice to compliment the heavier items typically served up on the holiday table. @seafoodgourmetnj


In Thyme in Moonachie are absolute pros when it comes to catering special events and for this holiday season will be serving up Goffle Farm turkey, grilled tenderloin and their signature macaroni and cheese - yes, please! @inthymecateredevents


Paul’s House of Fish in Cresskill will wow you with their platters of fresh crab legs, shrimp, and scallops, as well as a variety of other catering items, to diversify your holiday menu.  Warning - their crabmeat appetizer with signature dipping sauce is very hard to walk away from! @paulshouseoffish


Jerry’s Gourmet in Englewood offers up such variety you may want to carve out some extra time when you pick up your catering order to peruse their selection of wines and oils.  We may not be traveling to Italy quite yet, but you can surely escape here for a bit. @jerrysgourmetandmore


Great Foods Market in Oradell had us with their vegetable varieties, cranberry mold with toasted walnuts and pineapple and mixed berry pie!  The simple yet delicious twist on the original holiday fixings aim to spice up the holiday palate.  @greatfoodsmarket


Black Magic Bakehouse in Paramus has simplified the decision making process with their ‘pastry box’ that includes a very unique mix of curated desserts, one of which is a cranberry goat cheese cheesecake that has piqued our curiosity! @blackmagicbakehouse


Kurly Kurtosh in Hackensack literally offers up a twist on dessert with their signature Kurl that can be topped with your choice of dynamic flavors.  @kurlykurtosh


Rispoli Pastry Shop in Emerson has been serving up the community for 3 generations with their traditional desserts that have become a ‘must have’ on many holiday tables across Bergen County. @rispolipastryshop1937


The Cake Fairy in Harrington Park will elevate your dessert table to the next level with their delicious and beautifully done pies and cakes, not to mention a DIY cookie set to keep the kids busy. @cakefairymagic


Creaminals in Tenafly is a relatively new bakery who specializes in baking the most amazing breads, including their Thanksgiving Bird Bread, Babka and challah which we are oh-so-Thankful for! @creaminals.usa


Piece of Cake, delivering to Bergen County, is THE ice cream you need to top off that pie.  The business originally focused on delivering their stand-out gelato, ice cream and desserts to some of Bergen County’s top restaurants, but pivoted post-pandemic to also bring the deliciousness into the homes of enamored ice cream lovers across the county. @piece_of_cake


Everything Just Baked, while just outside of Bergen County, is a MUST on our list of holiday sweets because just look at the works of art these teens have created!  Custom bottles, cake jars and strawberry cream pie?!  Wow, just wow. @everythingjustbaked


This year, we are especially thankful to all of these New Jersey small business owners who bring seriously impressive food skills to our neighborhoods across Bergen County.  Cheers!

Related Posts